Don’t Judge by Appearances

Disabled Permit OnlyBy Wayne Connell, Founder and President of the Invisible Disabilities Association 

Have you ever seen someone get out of a car parked in a space reserved for people with disabilities, who did not LOOK disabled? Did it make you feel very uncomfortable or even upset? Did you let them know of your disapproval by giving them a dirty look or yelling at them?

Well, you are not alone. Many people are very disturbed by the sight of a seemingly mobile person taking the space of someone who is truly in need of it. After all, we want to protect the rights of people for whom these spaces are reserved!

However, in our efforts to help those who deserve these parking spaces, we actually may be hurting someone who has a legal right and a legitimate need to park there. How can this be true, you ask? Isn’t it obvious who does and who does not have a disability?

Let me Sherri Connell on Scooter 2.share the following story about my wife, Sherri.

It was a weekend afternoon, and Sherri wanted to head to the department store to pick up some items. She knew that driving would be tough enough, but she felt spending time with her niece would be worth the difficulty of the trip.  

Sherri and her niece pulled into the store parking lot, and she drove around until she found an accessible spot near the front. Sherri pulled out her accessible placard and placed it on the back of the mirror. She then proceeded into the store with her niece to shop.  

Once inside, they looked for an electric motorized cart. They located one and proceeded around the store. Of course, being in her late twenties and looking much younger, Sherri would elicit stares from people wondering why she was using the cart. Some even wondered out loud, especially children who would point and ask “Mommy, what’s wrong with her?”  

Why anyone would ride one of the store scooters unless they really needed it is beyond me. Sherri’s scooter at home goes 8 miles an hour and has head lights, tail lights and a headrest. The mall carts crawl along slowly, and everyone stares at you.

Sherri and her niece finished up their shopping and returned to their car. Sherri started the car and looked in the mirror and noticed a police car with its lights flashing right behind her, blocking her in. There was an immediate knock on her window. Startled, she rolled down her window and an officer stated that she was not allowed to park there, because she was not handicapped.  

Sherri said that the placard was hers and she handed the officer her license, her placard registration and a multiple sclerosis (MS) card. Sherri mentioned that she had the right to park there, because she was disabled with MS and had gotten approval from her doctor and the motor vehicle department.  

The officer replied, “I don’t care how many multiple problems you have, you can’t park there. I saw you walk inside and back to the car, and you looked fine to me.”  

After about 10 minutes of trying to explain her disability to the officer, Sherri started to get quite frustrated. She then asked very politely for the officer’s name and badge number, and if he would please move his car. Of course, her nervous system started to work overtime and her brain went into fight or flight mode. Luckily for the officer, he said he would move his car. Then he stated, “See those people over in that Cadillac, they are not handicapped either.” 

The conclusion of the story is that the officer was eventually reprimanded for the way he was hassling people who had the legitimate right to park in accessible parking.

The general qualifications for accessible parking spaces include those using wheelchairs, walkers, crutches, canes and assist dogs. Nonetheless, most of us do not realize they also include certain impaired functions of the heart or lungs, as well as conditions which are worsened to a specified impairment by walking a certain distance.

People with a variety of disabilities may qualify to park in these spots. Moreover, not all impairments are readily evident to the onlooker. Because of this, we refer to conditions which cause debilitating symptoms that are not so apparent from the outside as “invisible disabilities.”

There are millions of people who are forced to contend with serious illnesses, injuries and circumstances, which have left them with mountains to climb every time they take a step. Most people do not realize a person can have hindrances on the inside, which may not be visible on the outside. Their restrictions may not be conspicuous at a glance, but their pain, limitations and inability to function normally can be debilitating.

What may seem easy to you may seem like a 14,000 foot hurdle to them. Many even collapse in stores, become very dizzy and weak or even black-out. Being able to park close to the entrance of a building when they need to allows them to run an errand they otherwise would not have been able to conquer.

At any rate, the purpose of accessible spaces is to assist those with many types of disabilities and health conditions. For those with various types of limitations, the spots help make it possible for them to shop or visit the doctor.

How do you know who can park in an accessible space and who cannot? Look for a temporary or permanent placard in the front window or a disabled license plate. These items are received after an application, which is completed by a patient’s doctor, is approved by the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV).

Each state’s DMV has specific guidelines and requirements the person must meet in order to receive a placard or license plate. Most states take into consideration the impairments due to certain conditions, as well as the implications stemming from aggravations of these conditions. Therefore, if a person is issued a license and is displaying it, then they have the legal, medical right to park there.

The following are few assumptions regarding accessible parking:

  • Assumption 1 – Drivers can simply request a placard from the DMV without any proof or documentation.  

Drivers cannot request an accessible plate or placard without a form completed by a licensed physician and with their verifiable license number.

  • Assumption 2 – Doctors are irresponsibly filling out forms for patients. 

Doctors have no personal gain by doing so.

  • Assumption 3 – Drivers are borrowing a placard from a relative. 

Many people believe this happens often, but do not personally know anyone doing so. At any rate, we cannot assume someone is using a placard that does not belong to them, because they do not “look” like they have a disability.

If someone personally knows an individual who has stolen or borrowed a placard, they can file a complaint with the DMV. If we have further concerns with the application and qualification process, we should consider using the legislative process to address them, rather than confronting individuals in a parking lot.

Chances are the person displaying a placard or plate is in fact parked legally and needs the space for physical and/or medical reasons. As you can imagine, it is difficult enough to live with such illnesses, injuries and disabilities that wreak havoc in one’s life without being harassed every time one needs to go shopping or to the doctor. Finally, if a person is displaying a license to park in an accessible parking space, try offering a hand, instead of a visual judgment. After all…the people you are graciously intending to defend may be standing right in front of you!

This article was first published on Disability.Blog by Disability.gov. October 31, 2012.

Photo courtesy of Hernando County, Florida Tax Collector

RELATED ARTICLES:

Being Truly Thankful

But You LOOK Good! on Disability.gov

Don’t Judge by Appearances

IDA Makes the “Top 10 Guest blogs of 2012″ on Disability.gov

Invisible No More!

It’s All in Your Head

Join the Expedition

Learning the Language of Invisible Disabilities

Looks Can Be Deceiving

The Visible Invisible Disability (coming soon)

What’s So Funny About …

 

About Wayne

Wayne is the Founder & President of the Invisible Disabilities Association (IDA). His inspiration for IDA is His wife, Sherri, who lives with Multiple Sclerosis, Lyme Disease, Neurological Chemical Intolerance, Traumatic Brain Injury and Anaphylaxis Food Allergies. Wayne is the Author of the booklet, But You LOOK Good! How to Encourage and Understand People Living with Illness and Pain. He has spoken at seminars, conferences, health fairs and banquets to create awareness, education and support. His personal experience includes that of a professional, multi-tasking husband caregiver with an extensive background in management, media and technology. This man on a mission quickly launched IDA into a world-wide outreach for millions living with invisible disabilities. Wayne and the IDA Executive and Advisory Teams reach out to others living with illness, pain and injury around the world. They bring encouragement and awareness about invisible disabilities to friends, family, co-workers and businesses through websites, projects, articles, pamphlets, seminars, events, videos, radio and social networks.

[Top of Page]

Alert Dogs Put Their Sniffers to Work to Save Lives

Photo Copyright Diabetic Alert Dogs

We all know that a dog’s sense of smell is more keen than a human’s. In fact, according to Dan Warren, a Virginia dog breeder, humans have about 5 million nose receptors, but dogs have about 250 million!

But, did you know that dogs can detect very subtle fluctuations in blood sugar levels? Warren’s company, Diabetic Alert Dogs by Warren Retrievers trains dogs to alert their owner when their blood sugar is dropping, but is still within normal range. Warren is also the Founder, President and CEO of Guardian Angel Service Dogs, the non-profit arm that provides awareness and funding for families to receive a diabetic alert dog.

“They also train dogs to help others with ‘invisible disabilities,’ Warren says, ‘including post-traumatic stress disorder and autism” (salisburypost.com).

Dogs can also be trained to alert their owners of seizures, anxiety, blood pressure and more by barking, pawing and/or licking. Some dogs even know how to dial 9-1-1.

Read Full Article

ARTICLE RESOURCES

Diabetic alert dogs can sniff out health problems. Katie Scarvey. salisburypost.com. Lifestyle. February 19, 2012.

Diabetic Alert Dogs by Warren Retrievers

Guardian Angel Service Dogs

Photo Copyright Diabetic Alert Dogs by Warren Retrievers

RELATED STORIES FROM IDA

Fearless: Service Dogs Offer Hope and Peace of Mind

IDA’s Service Animal Links Page

More Than Just a Pet

NEW ADA Revisions Limit “Service Animals” to Dogs

About

The Invisible Disabilities Association (IDA) encourages, educates and connects people and organizations touched by illness, pain and disability around the globe. Formerly known as The Invisible Disabilities Advocate, IDA was founded in 1997 and incorporated in 2004 as a 501(c)(3) non-profit. IDA reaches out through our websites, projects, articles, pamphlets, booklet, social network, resources, videos, radio interviews, seminars, events and more! Get the word out! Share a link to our articles and pages with Google Plus, Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter and through Email by clicking on the Share link. Leave a comment!

[Top of Page]

Fearless: Service Dogs Offer Hope and Peace of Mind

www.GuardianAngelServiceDogs.orgI subscribe to a blog called Fear-Less. It’s about taking charge of your life … moving through fear to the truth … which is never words and is always the feeling. Fear-less means having less fear, but FEARLESS … well that means intrepid, brave, daring and courageous. All synonyms for people living with an invisible disability—every second of every day. IDA, the Invisible Disabilities Association, has a new motto: Invisible No More. And, to do that … to be that, you have to be FEARLESS.

One way to be invisible no more is to show up to life every day with a service dog at your side. These highly trained dogs step into the darkness and help individuals – and their families – cope every day with pain and fear and rise above it. These folks begin to have hope. To believe that today, just for today, it’s going to be OK. And, Hope is Good!

Not only does a service dog offer hope, peace of mind and help with the fear and pain – they are a beacon that allows the public to understand that sometimes what they can’t see is really the truth. Heads turn when a service dog and his handler walk into a room, and just by being present they help raise awareness about invisible disabilities. It’s not uncommon to hear whispers of “why does that person need a service dog, they look OK”, or “they’re certainly not blind or in a wheelchair, why do they need a dog?”

At Guardian Angel Service Dogs, not only do we provide hope for people fearlessly coping with invisible disabilities, we are raising awareness about the myriad of ways that service dogs can help people who “look good”.

In this season of giving and gratitude, I’m grateful that there are people who make profound changes in the world around them by fearlessly navigating their life with a service dog by their side.

RELATED ARTICLES FROM IDA

IDA’s Service Animal Links Page

More Than Just a Pet

NEW ADA Revisions Limit “Service Animals” to Dogs

UPDATE on Author: Sue Kindred has resigned from her position with Guardian Angel Service Dogs.

About Sue Kindred

Sue Kindred is the former Executive Director of Guardian Angel Service Dogs, Inc, a non-profit organization whose mission is to provide awareness about service dogs, as well as providee service dogs for individuals and families struggling with invisible disabilities. Additional Resources Diabetic Alert Dogs and Warren Retrievers.

[Top of Page]

Ontario Woman Strives to Make Town More Accessible

Port Hope, Ontario resident, Selena Forsyth, gives of her time to make her town accessible for people with disabilities.

“Ms. Forsyth is Port Hope’s Accessibility Advisory Committee chairwoman and since 2004, the committee, through its ‘Access for All’ activities, has increased awareness of barriers people with visible and invisible disabilities in the community face each day. Its goal is creation of an environment that offers people with disabilities the same opportunities as those offered the able-bodied. Improvements initiated through council’s annual participation in the event exercises have helped make Port Hope one of the most accessible towns in Ontario, she says.”

Read Full Story

ARTICLE RESOURCE:

Walk a mile in her shoes. Northumberland News. The Independent. June 05, 2011.

About

The Invisible Disabilities Association (IDA) encourages, educates and connects people and organizations touched by illness, pain and disability around the globe. Formerly known as The Invisible Disabilities Advocate, IDA was founded in 1997 and incorporated in 2004 as a 501(c)(3) non-profit. IDA reaches out through our websites, projects, articles, pamphlets, booklet, social network, resources, videos, radio interviews, seminars, events and more! Get the word out! Share a link to our articles and pages with Google Plus, Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter and through Email by clicking on the Share link. Leave a comment!

[Top of Page]

New ADA Revisions Limit “Service Animals” to Dogs

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) regulations were revised and published in the Federal Register on September 15, 2010. In addition to clarifications made to “service animal” regulations, a revision on the definition of a service animal was also made.

Most of us are familiar with Guide Dogs for the blind or visually impaired and Hearing Dogs for those who are deaf or hearing impaired. We may even know of Service Dogs that provide assistance to people using wheelchairs.

Yet, many do not realize there are many other types of disabilities that can be helped with a service animal. For example, someone with a seizure disorder or diabetes may be alerted by their service animal to impending attacks before the person can detect them and is able to get to a safe place or take precautions. A service animal can often retrieve an item or remind someone to take their medications.

On the other hand, although very valuable to the lives of many, animals used primarily for emotional support, companionship or therapy have never been considered to be service animals. None of the above have ever had public access rights in the past, nor do they now. Although therapy animals which are trained to provide therapy in certain environments have been allowed to access such places as nursing homes, schools and hospitals, their entrance has been by permission and not by disability law.

A service animal must be able to “…work or perform tasks for the benefit of an individual with a disability…” (DOJ). As a result of common confusion of what determined an animal to be a service animal, clarifications on such requirements were made.

In addition to the expanded definition of service animals, it was also revised to limit the type of animal used. Previously, the term left the option open for people with disabilities to choose the use of such animals as a monkey, cat, bird or pig as their service animal. Now, the regulation states, “Service animal means any dog…” (DOJ).  Effective March 15, 2011, this restriction will be applied (with some limited exception to miniature horses).

Regarding the canine limitation, the executive director of the Helping Hands: Monkey Helpers for the Disabled told Christine Cullen, Staff Writer for the Ocean City Today, the ADA changes “will have little effect on how Helping Hands operates because the organization only trains its monkeys for in-home use. Talbert said they are not suited to go out in public anyway” (OCT).

In all, these new regulations do not restrict people from training and using any animal to assist them in their homes and private spaces. Nonetheless, they will no longer be considered a service animal in relation to access of public places.

RESOURCES:

(DOJ) “Highlights of the Final Rule to Amend the Department of Justice’s Regulation IMplementing Title III of the ADA.” Department of Justice. ADA Home Page. Last updated October 7, 2010. www.ada.gov/regs2010/factsheets/title3_factsheet.html (Accessed 11.9.2010).

(OCT) “Federal law sttes only canines now qualify as disabled service animals.” Christine Cullen. Ocean City Today. August 6, 2010. http://www.oceancitytoday.net/news/2010-08-06/Top_News/Federal_law_states_only_canines_now_qualify_as_dis.html (Accessed 11.9.2010).

ADDITIONAL READING:

How was the definition of “service animal” changed July 23, 2010? Final Rule for Title IITitle II Fact Sheet / Text of Revised Title II RegulationFinal Rule for Title IIITitle III Fact SheetText of Revised Title III Regulation

Woman with Cryoglobulinemia and Her Service Dog Bring Hope to Others

Until Tuesday: A Wounded Warrior and the Golden Retriever Who Saved Him

Until Tuesday Video

The Invisible Disabilities Association is not a legal authority. Please seek advice from the ADA, an attorney or other proper authority to help define and apply laws and regulations.

About

The Invisible Disabilities Association (IDA) encourages, educates and connects people and organizations touched by illness, pain and disability around the globe. Formerly known as The Invisible Disabilities Advocate, IDA was founded in 1997 and incorporated in 2004 as a 501(c)(3) non-profit. IDA reaches out through our websites, projects, articles, pamphlets, booklet, social network, resources, videos, radio interviews, seminars, events and more! Get the word out! Share a link to our articles and pages with Google Plus, Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter and through Email by clicking on the Share link. Leave a comment!

[Top of Page]

   [Top of Page]

website security


Copyright 1997-2012, Invisible Disabilities Association. A 501(c)(3) Non-Profit Organization.
All rights reserved. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use
Disclaimer: The data contained in this web site are for informational purposes only and are not to be construed as medical or legal advice. IDA is not endorsing or promoting the content of other websites, by listing their links and cannot be held responsible for their contents. Please seek a medical or legal professional for advice.